Experience · Public
Choosing a sperm donor alone at my kitchen table on a Sunday
Welcoming shared experiences
The catalog looks like a dating site designed by bureaucrats. Eye colour, height, education, a little audio clip where a stranger says things like "I would describe myself as thoughtful." I had a cup of tea going cold and a spreadsheet of criteria I kept editing then immediately feeling stupid about.
At first I filtered like it was a shopping exercise — tall, healthy family history, similar colouring to mine. Then I hit a wall of questions the filters can't answer: does it matter that he's musical? That he describes a childhood that sounds warm? That he wrote a letter to the potential child that made me cry at the kitchen table on a Sunday afternoon?
I called my sister and read her two profiles out loud. She said "you're not choosing his genes, you're choosing the story you'll be able to tell your kid." That reframed it completely. I stopped optimising for phenotype and started thinking about what I'd want to be able to say in fifteen years.
I picked the one whose staff impressions mentioned he asked questions back. It felt right in a way the criteria never had.
Ordering sperm for courier delivery still feels surreal — like Amazon for the most consequential purchase of my life. But this is how it goes now, and honestly, I'm more at peace with my weird Sunday process than I expected.
Community content · Not clinically reviewed. Personal experiences do not establish what care is right for you.